31 03 2008
Why top ten sites on alexa are so crapy ?
By Charles, 31 03 2008 à 00:23 - Second season
Have you ever wonder why top sites are always the most dumb, crappy, lousy, idiotic ones ?
I 've just discovered that tool named Alexa that ranks websites according to their popularity. And I was staggered to see that top sites ranked there were the most creepy and stoopid websites I know.
Yes, most of them are well-known and established websites. But, all things considered, I find them dull, ugly and definitely useless. They do not offer high value service, they have poor design, they are basically boring.
At this stage, you might think I am completely nuts (which is surely true, but for others reasons, you can't even suspect). Before you definitively settle your judgment on me, let me try to demonstrate to you how right I am saying that the most popular websites are the most crappy ones.
I will focus on the top ten sites in United States, because I find them more representatives of what people look for on the web, and I don't want my point to be polluted by some Chinese unintelligible webstuff, or by European's usual misunderstandings of what things really are. (As a French myself, I am pretty well-informed about our huge capacity of misunderstanding we have as Europeans)
I want to see the truth of what interests people on Internet in the country that invented Internet.
Here are Alexa top ten sites in USA :
1. Google
Google is my friend. I am sure it deserves to be number one.
But it intrigues me that Google is the most used website in the world.
Is the web so messy we need a robot to search for us ?
What are people looking for they cannot find by themselves. Let's have a look at Google Zeitgeist for 2007
It's amazing to see that among the 10 fastest Rising requests, you have at least 8 you just need to put a dotcom in the end on the top of browser to get to..
What the point of typing "Facebook" or "Youtube" in google in you already know their name ?
As for the Iphone, I am sure that if you think 10 seconds, you can easily guess where you could find it.
2. Yahoo
There is all you need, on Yahoo : mail, chat, search engine, news, answers, videos, shopping, horoscope, weather...and a pretty loud amount of advertising.
I wonder why people on Yahoo need to go elsewhere. With all this stuff, you don't need no other website anymore.
So I guess Yahoo get so much traffic because it retains the early-adopters of Internet, who had never managed to quit the site since the beginning of the web, and keep on trying new services and new services...till they die.
3.Myspace
I just can't figure out why people spend so much time on a website so ugly and so much in a shambles.
There is more than 200 billions users on Myspace, who can you find there in such a mess of stinky design and musician wannabes ?
No real friend for sure.
4. Youtube
Ok. People are fed up with TV boring broadcast. They want to watch real stuff on the Internet. Something new, something real, something deep, something fun...
Here is the more viewed video on Youtube : Evolution of Dance
This is the evidence they should go back to TV. At least, it creates jobs : scriptwriters get paid for this.
5. Facebook
Someone posted on your Superwall. You have 1890 friends request. Someone tagged a photo of you naked. Sally poked you, poke back ? You have 46 "hug me hard" invitations. You have 4 "what stupid lamer are you" test invitations ? Someone kissed you, want to know who it is ? You have been invited to "fed up with facebook, claim it to the world" group. Jack sent you a snowball. Dick Tracy bited your werewolf, bite back ? Georges Bush accepted your friend request. Joe di Maggio challenged you in "Strip poker and apple pie" ...
Do I need to say more ?
6. Windows Live
Sincerely I don't understand what this website is about. It just look like a big download center for MS products.
I can't believe people need to download this kind of stuff. Wake up, guys, they are all included on every PC you buy !!
7. Ebay
I have an old and filthy floor cloth my mother gave me, when I first moved in my own flat. I want to get rid of it, but I can't resolve to throw it to the bin because I fear it can damage environment with all bacterial miasma it contains.
So I paint it red, I tell people it has been used to clean blood in one of Charles Manson's slaughters and suddenly it's worth 1500 bucks and I have fun during 7 days to look at fools bidding on that old floor cloth.
That's ebay.
Unfortunately, the last bidder offers 4 308 $ but "forgets" to pay, and here we are for five months of Ebay's dispute process.
So I agree there is no better thing to sell crap or to get scammed by Chinese Hustler, but what else can you do seriously with Ebay ?
8.Wikipedia
Wikipedia could be a great thing, a wonderful web encyclopedia, a new Babylon library, something huge which offers unlimited knowledge to anyone and for free.
But on Wikipedia knowledge is a fluctuating thing. Articles on a topic changes version everyday. So called Experts spend their time arguing about the color of Henri IV horse and there is often more content related to an article than in the article itself.
Too bad.
For your information, the color of Henri IV horse is white. No. gray. No blue with dots. Well, it may be red but this article is subject to caution.
9. Craiglist
Come on. Isn't all the success of this site due to the "casual encounter" section ?
I can't believe people spend so much time reading classified ads to delight themselves for other's lacks.
10.Microsoft Network
It's Microsoft second site on the top ten. Doesn't it look like the beginning of a monopole ?
Why didn't they put all their spying tools on the same website ?
Maybe it's a bug.
Well, to conclude with the desperate analysis of Alexa Us top ten websites, I could say there are only two options :
- First option : Alexa is not reliable
- Second option : People are dumb


